On November 1 at 4:00pm Eastern, we will be joined at UMW for a panel discussion about “Ethical Online Learning” by Kate Bowles, Alan Levine, Sean Michael Morris, and Liz Losh. RSVP here (not required), and if you can’t make it in person, watch the livestream and join us on the backchannel via #DoOO.
Online teaching is incredibly mundane. Or so it would seem given how infrequently people wave the banner of online teaching or champion online teachers. Much of the labor of online teaching is invisible. And most traditional approaches to online course design make teachers into mere facilitators or content providers, reducing teachers to bits.
My first forays into hybrid teaching were with one of my pedagogical mentors, R L Widmann, whom I began working with in 2001 to help develop her Virtual Shakespeare course. Because of my work with R L, my assumption has always been that online teaching can (and even should) be collaborative. (In 2015, we turned that course into a hybrid MOOC with on-ground components and over 20,000 students.)
When I started teaching fully online courses in 2007, I worked for Sean Michael Morris, who was Chair (at the time) of the English department for CCCOnline, the provider of online courses for the Community Colleges of Colorado. I did the thankless, and not altogether honorable, work of designing stock composition courses. About 30 – 50 sections of the courses I designed were “duped” and offered each term. 9 years later, the institution has only barely revised the courses (mostly to remove flexibility and add sterner instructions for students).
Years after I stopped working for CCCOnline, I’d still receive e-mails from students taking the courses, because teachers given a shell I’d designed would fail to update their instructor page, and my personal information would be left in the course. This happened many many times. Because of a very flawed system, 100s (and possibly 1000s) of students have believed I was their online teacher at an institution I had left many years before. The identity (and humanity) of the teachers of these courses mattered so little to everyone involved that this instructor page and its contents had grown vestigial. I suspect I’d still be receiving e-mails from CCCOnline students if I hadn’t obliterated the address I’d used on that page.
And, sadly, the most common e-mail I’d get from these students was concern about my absence from their course. The teacher hadn’t shown up to discussions or hadn’t shown up to grade student work, and because they also hadn’t shown up to edit their instructor information page, it was my absence that was felt by the students. I don’t begrudge these teachers. When I was teaching for CCCOnline, I was a road warrior adjunct, working at 4 institutions, teaching up to 9 courses per term. Even I sometimes forgot who I was. The problem was the precarious labor system (and bad instructional design decisions) that made all of this go.
Sean Michael Morris taught me how to teach online. And, while he worked as a department chair, Sean fought hard against the precarious labor system and the bad instructional design decisions being made (and still being made) at CCCOnline. He also helped me understand how to bring my full self to the work of teaching online. Sean has always said that he hates the internet, and this is also what makes him an excellent online teacher. He understands the limitations of the LMS and the complexities of digital identity, so he’s able to thoughtfully and compassionately navigate the work of teaching and learning online. Sean is, quite easily, the best online teacher I have known.
In preparing for DTLT’s upcoming panel at UMW about “Ethical Online Learning,” I wanted to find a way to champion more online teachers. The work of teaching online can be incredibly isolating, so I also wanted to give online teachers a list of people they could connect with. I started by putting the question to Twitter.
Assembling list of exemplary online teachers in and out of the LMS, ideally folks who’ve written about their work. Ideas? Links? Please RT.
— Jesse Stommel (@Jessifer) September 15, 2016
Almost immediately, I got an important question that helped me define the parameters for the list I’ve made here.
@Lawrie Positive examples, including various approaches, of online teaching broadly writ. Not to copy but to acknowledge and wonder at.
— Jesse Stommel (@Jessifer) September 15, 2016
What I’ve assembled are 15 online teachers active on Twitter who have inspired me (presented here in no particular order). I’ve also gathered a much longer list of crowd-sourced suggestions. Many of these are fully online teachers. Some teach courses of 25 students. Some teach to thousands. Some write about online learning in critical ways. Some are experimenting at the edge of on-ground and online learning. Some are online learners who have made their learning visible in ways that also makes them teachers.
1. Sean Michael Morris (@slamteacher)
“Post once, reply twice.”
Epitaph for online learning.#digped
— Sean Michael Morris (@slamteacher) February 18, 2016
2. Laura Gibbs (@OnlineCrsLady)
Today’s #growthmindset cat knows that learning is a superpower! More cats here: https://t.co/nP6QfJmIkW #MindsetPlay pic.twitter.com/gzON7vVrk2
— Laura Gibbs (@OnlineCrsLady) May 9, 2016
3. Al Filreis (@afilreis)
“ModPo: long live the online seminar.” Article today in PC Magazine: https://t.co/6IJGI788zi
— Al Filreis (@Afilreis) December 3, 2015
4. Maha Bali (@Bali_Maha)
Online Learning Experiences that Shape Us https://t.co/8ScuWxFHgp #edtech
— ℳąhą Bąℓi مها بالي (@Bali_Maha) February 9, 2016
5. Ana Salter (@AnaSalter)
My latest ProfHacker post looks at wrapping up + preparing for a new semester of my online Digital Culture class. https://t.co/g6IK5GXwWi
— Anastasia Salter (@AnaSalter) November 20, 2015
6. Alan Levine (@cogdog)
My 1st online teaching exp (2004) “Web-Based Teaching and Learning” http://t.co/QL9QIClO2C Course Descrip looks same http://t.co/oPIIf1zTST
— Alan Levine (@cogdog) February 17, 2015
7. Kathi Inman Berens (@kathiiberens)
My new post “The New Learning is Ancient”: http://t.co/HYYp4LJ4 On my F2F & virtual classroom. What can’t be digitized. #NITLE #MLA13 #ascj
— Kathi Inman Berens (@kathiiberens) December 6, 2012
8. Dave Cormier (@davecormier)
@Jessifer @raulpacheco @bonstewart @tressiemcphd @DrPetra Jesse and I spent an hour chatting about some of this once https://t.co/1TV6SWWTUx
— dave cormier (@davecormier) April 13, 2016
9. Cathy N. Davidson (@CathyNDavidson)
10 Things I’ve Learned (So Far) from Making a Meta-MOOC via @HybridPed http://t.co/98eTPBHXBt
— Cathy Davidson (@CathyNDavidson) January 16, 2014
1o. Donna Murdoch (@donnamurdoch)
I guest taught with @donnamurdoch and was awed by how generous a community she builds. I didn’t want to leave. https://t.co/qMb6Cd9kcB
— Jesse Stommel (@Jessifer) September 15, 2016
11. Michelle Pacansky-Brock (@brocansky)
Love letter to online learning by @brocansky https://t.co/R15oVazig0 @TLIatCI
— M Pacansky-Brock (@brocansky) April 26, 2016
12. Howard Rheingold (@hrheingold)
46 second video intro to The Peeragogy Handbook https://t.co/C8toJepLZR
— Howard Rheingold (@hrheingold) February 15, 2016
13. Steve Greenlaw (@sgreenla)
New blog post: “Journey into OER: My Quandary” https://t.co/mbQgbzdCtE Second in a series. @actualham @Jessifer @opencontent @VivienRolfe
— Steve Greenlaw (@sgreenla) February 1, 2016
14. Martha Burtis (@mburtis)
Was honored to speak last week for @DigPedLab. Full text of talk (and video/audio) are up today at @HybridPed https://t.co/GvNgD2OZT1
— Martha (@mburtis) August 20, 2016
15. George Veletsianos (@veletsianos)
Learner experiences with open online learning and #MOOCs e-book: http://t.co/C50WwMy8y5
— George Veletsianos (@veletsianos) September 24, 2013
Finally, one more extra special shout out to my dad, who teaches Psychology courses online for CCCOnline. He has always been one of my pedagogical models. He taught me that I wanted to teach. And I taught him right back. <3
16. Joe Stommel (@JoeStommel)
#4wordpedagogy always treat people well.
— Joe Stommel (@JoeStommel) May 1, 2016
Last, but certainly not least, the dozens of teachers also championed on Twitter in response to my call, many of whom I have admired for years and others I have only just discovered. It’s an amazing list of thoughtful, critical educators and technologists: @bonstewart @lizlosh @plowenthal @jgmac1106 @hypervisible @textpotential @profjuliette @Lorarts @KateMfD @profesor_curtis @GardnerCampbell @koutropoulos @rjhogue @tedmitew @CL_Moore @ReneeMiddlemost @amcollier @katiedigc @travisaholland @derekbruff @harmonygritz @kthompso @LisaMLane @mrkrndvs @johnjohnston @adamprocter @BryanMMathers @epilepticrabbit @krisshaffer @eylanezekiel @adelinekoh @iamjessklein @wiobyrne @oliverquinlan @mesterman @robert_schuetz @katrinamwehr @mizuko @MiaZamoraPhD @jenebbeler @jimgroom @harmonygritz @Jonthan_Worth @jadedid @LizFalconer80 @Chris_Friend @alexpickett
And I am certain there are many many more. These lists are nowhere near to complete (or even representative). Add the online teachers who have inspired you in the comments below, including folks that aren’t active on Twitter.
Kicking off the comments here by waxing poetic about a few more of the people in the second list who I admire. And I worked with that second list to think about online teaching as broadly considered as I could.
Again, nearly impossible to pick favorites among this list. And my choices are colored by my very specific North American context, so I hope others will add to this list.
George Station (@harmonygritz) — When I joined Google+ quite a few years ago, George (and a few of the others on this list) welcomed me into the community there. What I saw over many years is the way George builds community by connecting people. I have learned a lot from him about how social networks can be used to facilitate conversations — and about how social networks can be used as teaching spaces.
Chris Friend (@chris_friend) — I met Chris when he was a student in one of my online courses, but he took a leadership role there almost immediately. He brings an amazing introverted energy to his teaching, both online and face-to-face. He listens intently — so intently that students don’t stop talking. And his responses are thoughtful and empathetic.
Kate Bowles (@KateMfD) — One of the panelists coming to UMW (all the way from Australia) to participate in our “Ethical Online Learning” panel. She has taught me to think bigger about the world I live in — that my geographic context isn’t actually my context. I’ve cared about stuff happening on the other side of the planet, in part because of Kate. And this has changed the way I think about my online students and where they “live.” I’m still learning.
And I could do this all day for every other person in these lists and more.
Thank you all!
I open to advice, ideas or options I have to where and or how I can work 10 years online Teaching experience into something full time.
Thank you
Tim
John McWade at Before & After Magazine teaching design
Thanks for assembling this list, Jesse. I’m one or two degrees of separation from many of them. Too close to K12 and F2F to overlap directly, but I catch all the best RTs.
My impression is that most of the people above work in the humanities or in technology more broadly. I’m looking for exemplary online math teachers to learn from. Can you point me towards anybody?
Hi Dan, I definitely recommend Derek Bruff (@derekbruff). He’s in my second list above. But I’m hoping other folks will jump in here and suggest some more folks.
Adding a math teacher from Yavapai College in Arizona I vote Dave Graser located here: http://whyseemath.com/wp/ Only heard and saw greatness from his work.