Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/umwdtltc/public_html/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/umwdtltc/public_html/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/umwdtltc/public_html/wp-config.php:101) in /home/umwdtltc/public_html/wp-includes/feed-rss2.php on line 8
Online Learning – UMW Division of Teaching and Learning Technologies https://umwdtlt.com Mon, 26 Feb 2018 06:02:28 +0000 en hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 https://i0.wp.com/umwdtlt.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/cropped-dtlt-black1.png?fit=32%2C32&ssl=1 Online Learning – UMW Division of Teaching and Learning Technologies https://umwdtlt.com 32 32 103540615 Cat Facts, Animated GIFs, and Building Community Online https://umwdtlt.com/cat-facts-animated-gifs-and-building-community-online/ Thu, 03 Nov 2016 13:52:28 +0000 http://www.zachwhalen.net/?p=6404 Last year, I began using Slack in my classes, and in the early days of the Spring 2016 semester, I wrote a post about how I thought it was going and how it seemed to be filling in many of the communicative modalities otherwise occupied by an LMS like Canvas. After completing that semester and having now reflected a bit on how the online environment in Slack supported a sense of community among the four sections (two of mine plus one each by Lee Skallerup Bessette and Jesse Stommel, I want to do some analysis of what that Slack community looked like in terms of participation. My comments here extend some thoughts I originally shared in a presentation back in May.

Basically, I want to look further into an assumption I made in my original post, where I talked about the sense of community developing in my class’s Slack conversations. But what is a community? And what does the content shared in that space tell us about that community? Does the fact that a slack group of 120 people (students + faculty) produced around 5,000 messages over the course of a semester mean that we were “successful” in some way? And finally, how does my role within this community impact my impression of its cohesiveness and sense of shared purpose?

Numbers and graphs can’t tell the whole story, of course, but they start to illuminate a few things about our Slack group. Slack only provides detailed statistics to its paying users, so to produce the data for all of the charts and visualizations that follow, I simply exported the public message archive and cleaned that up in a spreadsheet.

First, I was curious about who participated in this conversation and who didn’t. So here’s a pie chart of the messages by source:

Here and elsewhere, a “message” is something someone typed into Slack, including interacting with integrations and bots, e.g. /giphy or /catfacts. This chart shows that, while students did do a lot of messaging (and there’s an additional 2.4K private messages that I’m not including), most of the communicating in this Slack group was done by the three instructors, of which I personally made up the vast majority, and the next largest chunk overall was the output or responses from various bots and integrations.

Clearly, a lot of the “participation” in this community is actually just me. It’s even more starkly visible in a network graph. For the visualization that appears below (or full screen here), a node represents a user (student’s names have been removed), and the size of the node indicates how many posts that user contributed. A connection between nodes records at least one instance of a user @-mentioning another user, which usually indicates a conversation. The thicker the line, the greater the number of mentions between the two.

I’m pleased by all of the connections in this graph, especially that it’s still relatively well-connected if you take me out of it (Right-click on my face and select “Hide”), but it’s hard not to worry about all the unconnected users floating out to the right. These are the same users that occupy the right side of this bar-graph:

A bar chart showing the number of messages in Zach's course

 

There are plenty of legitimate reasons these users may have had for not participating as much as the rest of us. Anecdotal information can fill that data-gap somewhat: some students had difficulty installing the platform or getting used to it, and others used it frequently but tended to lurk more than they posted. Moreover, I suspect that if I were to make a similar set of graphs for how and when people talk irl in my classes, I’d probably find a similar curve with me doing most of the talking, a few outliers doing almost none of the talking, and most others finding themselves somewhere in the middle.

So what about the content? What kinds of things were we talking about in all these messages? Here’s a word cloud:

Word cloud of Zach's class message contents

 

I know word clouds aren’t great at providing insights into a corpus, but I like that giphy stands out because it reveals how often we used the /giphy integration, and since pretty the only reason to use /giphy is to be silly, its popularity helps characterize the playful tone most often employed in our community.

To further explore tone, I looked into how we used emoji. Slack has a rich, easy-to-use emoji keyboard that also supports adding custom emoji, and, importantly, there are two ways emoji show up: 1) inside a regular message and 2) as a “reaction” to another message. Analyzing these two uses separately was essential to get a good read, because we used “in-message” emoji differently. For example, some groups tried to re-tell the novel we read using only emoji, so the emoji they used for recurring characters are inevitably going to show up quite a lot.

A bunch of emoijis
I couldn’t figure out how to make a more elegant or organic-looking “emoji cloud”, but here’s the best I could do using Emojipedia.org for most of the images, logarithmic scaling by popularity for size, and Packery.js for a condensed layout.

In the first cloud emoji used inside of messages, one finds that the cat face is the largest and most popular image, due to the popularity of /catfacts. The following cloud actually gives a better sense of our community, because it is less subject to ironic, sarcastic, or diegetic uses.

A group of emojis
This image presents the emoji used as reactions to others’ messages. The large thumbs up and the facetious poop pretty accurately convey the playful and supportive environment that reigned in our Slack team.

Taken together, these pictures of our community only provide a cursory glimpse of what, to me, really felt like an energetic, interactive community of learners engaged in the task of figuring things out and supporting each other along the way. I’m an optimist, though, and I look on the bright side of these data. Anecdotal evidence can’t avoid the trap of my own perspective as I look at this community through the lens of my experience with it. Clearly, I’m a biased witness, but my anecdotal, educated-guess feeling is that Slack affords community building in a way that is no worse than in-person classes. And if it’s more playful integrations help ease its adoption and encourage students to use those integrations to renegotiate the power relationships that otherwise could restrict conversation, then more the better.

This past Summer, Lee and I worked on a proposal to teach DGST 101 fully online, with Slack playing a major role in how we conceive of the class going forward. It’s my hope that, through the ways in which Slack’s adoption and continued use supported our sense of community across sections, it will also help provide a common ground for a community to develop via primarily asynchronous communication.

]]>
6404
Creating Community & Collaboration in Canvas https://umwdtlt.com/creating-community-collaboration-in-canvas/ Wed, 02 Nov 2016 14:19:32 +0000 http://umwdtlt.com/?p=53149 It really is quick and easy to create an online course — just upload some readings, write a couple automated quizzes, turn it on and walk away for the semester! In fact, the LMS and other instructional tech makes it possible to hobble together a course like this in no time flat and let them run on autopilot. I experienced one of these courses as an undergrad – there were readings followed by multiple choice quizzes for each chapter. I sat down with a pot of coffee, Google, and a textbook and earned three credits in anatomy in under 18 hours. The only reason I remember (and resent) this course is because Wells Fargo occasionally reminds me that I paid for those credits.

Obviously, that type of online experience is not good for the student, and cheapens the role of the faculty member in the educational experience. But the LMS can provide for a relatively rich online experience if you dig just a bit deeper into the interface. I’ll be going over some of these features in my upcoming design sprint, “More than a Data Dump: 10 Tools for Creating Meaningful Interaction in Canvas.” In the meantime, here are a few recommendations that apply to any LMS or online platform:

  1. Don’t be an egg! If you’ve ever used Twitter, you know that the default profile picture is a colored egg. This is a sign to other users that you are new, you aren’t good with technology and don’t know how to update your photo, you don’t care, or you’re a bot. Updating your photo in an LMS or other platform goes a long way toward humanizing you in any online space. We’ll go over how to do this and other ways to humanize yourself in Canvas during the design sprint!
  2. Death by discussion board. If you’ve ever taken an online course, you’ve probably encountered a discussion board. These have great potential, but leading discussions in an asynchronous online environment involves different strategies compared to in-class discussion. Prompts asking students to “respond to the reading” often fall flat because they are vague or cause cause students to worry about looking stupid in front of their peers. Giving students a way to respond that allows them to offer value or expertise is one way to reduce face-threat and spur more meaningful discussion. We’ll talk about this and walk through some features in Canvas that can help set the stage for quality, engaged discussions.
  3. Finally, I want to circle back around to assessment – what can we do beyond readings and quizzes? There are actually quite a few features in Canvas (and other LMSs) that provide for student-to-student interaction. If you’re teaching a writing-intensive course, you could make use of the robust peer-review features. This summer, I’ll be using the discussion board to have students submit digital projects. This allows them to showcase their work to their peers while giving me an opportunity to provide them with a score in the gradebook.

I’ll be returning to this topic later this month with additional strategies and “how-to” instructions specific to Canvas, the LMS we use here at the University of Mary Washington. If you’d like a more hands-on demo of these features, make sure to join us for “More than a Data Dump: 10 Tools for Creating Meaningful Interaction in Canvas” as part of our Digital Liberal Arts series at 4:00pm on Monday, November 7th in HCC 407.

]]>
53149
16 Creative Online Educators You Should Follow on Twitter Right Now https://umwdtlt.com/16-creative-online-educators-you-should-follow-on-twitter-right-now/ Thu, 27 Oct 2016 09:58:00 +0000 http://umwdtlt.com/?p=53088 On November 1 at 4:00pm Eastern, we will be joined at UMW for a panel discussion about “Ethical Online Learning” by Kate Bowles, Alan Levine, Sean Michael Morris, and Liz Losh. RSVP here (not required), and if you can’t make it in person, watch the livestream and join us on the backchannel via #DoOO.

Online teaching is incredibly mundane. Or so it would seem given how infrequently people wave the banner of online teaching or champion online teachers. Much of the labor of online teaching is invisible. And most traditional approaches to online course design make teachers into mere facilitators or content providers, reducing teachers to bits.

My first forays into hybrid teaching were with one of my pedagogical mentors, R L Widmann, whom I began working with in 2001 to help develop her Virtual Shakespeare course. Because of my work with R L, my assumption has always been that online teaching can (and even should) be collaborative. (In 2015, we turned that course into a hybrid MOOC with on-ground components and over 20,000 students.)

When I started teaching fully online courses in 2007, I worked for Sean Michael Morris, who was Chair (at the time) of the English department for CCCOnline, the provider of online courses for the Community Colleges of Colorado. I did the thankless, and not altogether honorable, work of designing stock composition courses. About 30 – 50 sections of the courses I designed were “duped” and offered each term. 9 years later, the institution has only barely revised the courses (mostly to remove flexibility and add sterner instructions for students).

Years after I stopped working for CCCOnline, I’d still receive e-mails from students taking the courses, because teachers given a shell I’d designed would fail to update their instructor page, and my personal information would be left in the course. This happened many many times. Because of a very flawed system, 100s (and possibly 1000s) of students have believed I was their online teacher at an institution I had left many years before. The identity (and humanity) of the teachers of these courses mattered so little to everyone involved that this instructor page and its contents had grown vestigial. I suspect I’d still be receiving e-mails from CCCOnline students if I hadn’t obliterated the address I’d used on that page.

And, sadly, the most common e-mail I’d get from these students was concern about my absence from their course. The teacher hadn’t shown up to discussions or hadn’t shown up to grade student work, and because they also hadn’t shown up to edit their instructor information page, it was my absence that was felt by the students. I don’t begrudge these teachers. When I was teaching for CCCOnline, I was a road warrior adjunct, working at 4 institutions, teaching up to 9 courses per term. Even I sometimes forgot who I was. The problem was the precarious labor system (and bad instructional design decisions) that made all of this go.

Sean Michael Morris taught me how to teach online. And, while he worked as a department chair, Sean fought hard against the precarious labor system and the bad instructional design decisions being made (and still being made) at CCCOnline. He also helped me understand how to bring my full self to the work of teaching online. Sean has always said that he hates the internet, and this is also what makes him an excellent online teacher. He understands the limitations of the LMS and the complexities of digital identity, so he’s able to thoughtfully and compassionately navigate the work of teaching and learning online. Sean is, quite easily, the best online teacher I have known.

In preparing for DTLT’s upcoming panel at UMW about “Ethical Online Learning,” I wanted to find a way to champion more online teachers. The work of teaching online can be incredibly isolating, so I also wanted to give online teachers a list of people they could connect with. I started by putting the question to Twitter.

 

Almost immediately, I got an important question that helped me define the parameters for the list I’ve made here.

 

What I’ve assembled are 15 online teachers active on Twitter who have inspired me (presented here in no particular order). I’ve also gathered a much longer list of crowd-sourced suggestions. Many of these are fully online teachers. Some teach courses of 25 students. Some teach to thousands. Some write about online learning in critical ways. Some are experimenting at the edge of on-ground and online learning. Some are online learners who have made their learning visible in ways that also makes them teachers.

1. Sean Michael Morris (@slamteacher)

 

2. Laura Gibbs (@OnlineCrsLady)

 

3. Al Filreis (@afilreis)

 

4. Maha Bali (@Bali_Maha)

 

5. Ana Salter (@AnaSalter)

 

6. Alan Levine (@cogdog)

 

7. Kathi Inman Berens (@kathiiberens)

 

8. Dave Cormier (@davecormier)

 

9. Cathy N. Davidson (@CathyNDavidson)

 

1o. Donna Murdoch (@donnamurdoch)

 

11. Michelle Pacansky-Brock (@brocansky)

 

12. Howard Rheingold (@hrheingold)

 

13. Steve Greenlaw (@sgreenla)

 

14. Martha Burtis (@mburtis)

 

15. George Veletsianos (@veletsianos)

 

Finally, one more extra special shout out to my dad, who teaches Psychology courses online for CCCOnline. He has always been one of my pedagogical models. He taught me that I wanted to teach. And I taught him right back. <3

16. Joe Stommel (@JoeStommel)

 

Last, but certainly not least, the dozens of teachers also championed on Twitter in response to my call, many of whom I have admired for years and others I have only just discovered. It’s an amazing list of thoughtful, critical educators and technologists: @bonstewart @lizlosh @plowenthal @jgmac1106 @hypervisible @textpotential @profjuliette @Lorarts @KateMfD @profesor_curtis @GardnerCampbell @koutropoulos @rjhogue @tedmitew @CL_Moore @ReneeMiddlemost @amcollier @katiedigc @travisaholland @derekbruff @harmonygritz @kthompso @LisaMLane @mrkrndvs @johnjohnston @adamprocter @BryanMMathers @epilepticrabbit @krisshaffer @eylanezekiel @adelinekoh @iamjessklein @wiobyrne @oliverquinlan @mesterman @robert_schuetz @katrinamwehr @mizuko @MiaZamoraPhD @jenebbeler @jimgroom @harmonygritz @Jonthan_Worth @jadedid @LizFalconer80 @Chris_Friend @alexpickett

And I am certain there are many many more. These lists are nowhere near to complete (or even representative). Add the online teachers who have inspired you in the comments below, including folks that aren’t active on Twitter.

]]>
53088
Ethical Online Learning: A Town Hall https://umwdtlt.com/ethical-online-learning-a-town-hall/ Tue, 25 Oct 2016 15:57:04 +0000 http://umwdtlt.com/?p=53072 How can we effectively and ethically integrate online learning at primarily on-ground institutions? Is this a technological challenge, an administrative challenge, or a pedagogical challenge?

For our next Digital Liberal Arts town hall conversation, we will be joined by an international group with experience researching online education, teaching online, teaching MOOCs, administrating online programs, and more.

PANELISTS:
Elizabeth Losh, William & Mary
Sean Michael Morris, Middlebury College
Kate Bowles, University of Wollongong, Australia
Alan Levine, Independent Speaker and Consultant

These four have given considerable thought to the shape and nature of education in the digital age. They are dreamers, skeptics, researchers, and artists. Together, they will push us to think about new approaches to online learning. Panelists will each offer short position statements before engaging our community in an open conversation.

UMW is thinking increasingly about ways to experiment with online learning — for Summer courses and for degree programs aimed at non-traditional students. Before we travel too far down this path, I find it important to pause and consider the broader implications of this work — and to talk very directly about how this work can be done thoughtfully and ethically. Having the diverse perspectives of these four panelists will help us as we continue to create our own conversations, as we continue to not shy away from asking the hard questions of online learning, as we continue to be models for other institutions exploring digital pedagogy. We need everyone at the table as we do this work.

Some of the questions we’ll consider during the Town Hall will include:

  • What would a liberal arts online program look like? How can we imagine online learning that is “high-touch,” “socially engaged,” “critical,” and “active”?
  • How would such a program be functionally and pedagogically different than a conventional online program? What are some of the models for this kind of work? 
  • What does (and can) online teaching look like? What are the possible pitfalls and opportunities? 
  • What are the challenges in administering online programs? 
  • How can we bring students more fully into the conversation about online learning — about the changing shape of their education?

In 2012, I wrote a piece called “Online Learning: a Manifesto.” Much of the conversation has changed since 2012, but much of it is still the same. In that piece, I argue,

The first mistake of many online classes is that they try to replicate something we do in face-to-face classes, mapping the (sometimes pedagogically-sound, sometimes bizarre) traditions of on-ground institutions onto digital space. Trying to make an online class function exactly like an on-ground class is a missed opportunity. There’s a lot that happens in F2F classrooms that just can’t be replicated in an online environment, and that’s okay. Better to ask ourselves what can be achieved online and what sorts of classes (or learning experiences) we can construct to leverage the potentials of the specific interface or community.

This is the work before us at University of Mary Washington — to carefully consider the unique and deeply human work we’ve done as an institution and how we will continue to do different (but still unique and deeply human) work in digital space.

Join us for this conversation on Tuesday, November 1 at 4:00pm in the Hurley Convergence Center Digital Auditorium. The event is free and open to the public. RSVP here (not required).

If you can’t make it in person you can find the livestream here and join the backchannel on Twitter with #DoOO.

Also, mark your calendars for the next event in our Digital Liberal Arts series. On Monday, November 7th at 4pm, Nigel Haarstad will host a Design Sprint, “More than a Data Dump: 10 Tools for Creating Meaningful Interaction in Canvas.” Our plan is to take some of the bigger issues we discuss at the Town Hall and bring them to practical application.

]]>
53072
The Failure of an Online Program https://umwdtlt.com/the-failure-of-an-online-program/ Thu, 20 Oct 2016 14:27:42 +0000 http://umwdtlt.com/?p=52954 Sean Michael Morris will be joining us at UMW on November 1 as part of a panel on “Ethical Online Learning” in our Digital Liberal Arts series. Sean is an Instructional Designer for the Office of Digital learning at Middlebury College. He is also the director of Digital Pedagogy Lab. He is interested in the practice of critical digital pedagogy as a social justice movement and has been working in and around digital learning environments for 17 years, in capacities ranging from instructional design to instructor to program chair. He identifies strongly with the post-digital, and he learns, teaches, and theorizes from a contemplative perspective.

It’s evening. An Irish pub in Louisville, Colorado. Fish and chips. Beer. A game of soccer on the TV. I’m sitting down with one of my faculty to revisit the department’s Developmental English course (ENG 090). My goal: bring the course fully online, eliminate the text book, and make it a deeper learning and community building experience for all who enroll. The trick is, almost no one enrolls in ENG 090 because they want to. They enroll because they failed a test. How do you take a student from “You failed. Take this class.” to “Writing is fun!” And how do you do that online?

My meeting started with that question, and the course itself grew out of more questions. We spent our time asking how a thing could be done — “How can we eliminate a text book?” “How can we make assignments that are meaningful, student-centered, and relevant?” “How can we make this course equally accessible to native English speakers and second language learners?” — and very rarely, if ever, saying that something could not be done. We opened our minds to the ways that we could open the LMS. We decided on quizzes that were iterative, formative and not summative. We chose to create a voice for the course that was friendly and work that united students in collaboration rather than making them compete against the machine or us.

That evening, and in the semesters that followed, the ENG 090 course evolved to become more open, more engaging, and over time inspired higher and higher retention.

I was Program Chair of the English Department at an institution that existed next to the community college system in Colorado. We provided online courses for all 13 system colleges. Because our audience — teachers, students, on-ground administrators — was diverse in both their expectations and abilities, always at the fore of any course design was ease of use. How flexible and facile could our courses be? How low-maintenance, too, and thus adoptable? In addition, I faced my personal expectation that every course we offered be as pedagogically sound — and not just sound, but also as innovative as possible. Working within the dim corridors of the Blackboard and WebCT LMSs, it was often challenging to provide enough illumination to help learning happen.

I had long believed that online learning didn’t understand itself. That it was as a two-year-old child who discovers he can walk but doesn’t really understand the nuances of the ambulatory act, nor really even what walking’s for. For years — and especially after the widespread adoption of the LMS — there had been a kind of “because we can” attitude among instructional designers and online educators. No one was asking whether we should or, more importantly, what exactly online learning was for.

My institution at the time, like many then and many now, thrived in a climate of non-inquiry. We created courses that met state-mandated standards, that enjoyed consistently higher and higher enrollments (in my short tenure, my department went from offering 25 sections to 50 sections each term), and we aspired to be a model for online learning programs everywhere. On paper, we looked great. But failure was inevitable.

In Fall of 2012, the Developmental English course that was birthed that evening at the pub, and which has also enjoyed tremendous growth in enrollment and attendance over the last five years since I left my post, was redesigned. It was redesigned by the administration, Frankensteined together from bits and pieces of variations on the course, armed with incredibly rigid rubrics for discussion posting, assignments, and other student contributions, engorged with hard-to-take and hard-to-grade weekly quizzes, and derailed by inconsistencies between assignments, discussions, and lectures. Before this redesign, ENG 090 justified an offering of ten to fifteen sections in a single term. And the semester following, only four sections filled.

It seems natural to assume that students spread the word and chose to take the course at other institutions. What at one time was a meaningful, interesting developmental class had become a nightmare, a punishment for failing the English comprehension test.

So what went wrong? Clearly, instructional design choices are partly to blame. But why were those choices made?

A climate of non-inquiry can create a robust online learning program. But it corrupts that program from the bottom, up. A climate of non-inquiry, where we all hold our meetings with our blinders firmly strapped about our cheeks, corrodes the best-intentioned online programs because it allows us as administrators and teachers to never be learners. And the truth is, there is a great deal of learning still to be done. An insistence on doing things as we’ve always done them, on trying to match piece to piece, part to part, learning object to learning object, only limits us. Non-inquiry blinds us to the environment in which we’re actually teaching.

Online learning not only will fail; in its current iterations it already has. We should not try to fix what’s wrong with online learning now; instead, we should pretend it never happened, start from scratch, and begin playfully outside the borders of how we’ve always taught and how we relate to the machines that can help us teach. The only way we can surface from this quagmire of poor teaching, uninformed design, and lackluster (or lack of) pedagogy is to admit that we’ve wandered a long way down the wrong path. We need to sit down, have some fish and chips, maybe a beer, and start asking questions again. Freely, openly, curiously, and without fear.

This piece was the second of a four-part colloquy of articles, each piece contributed by authors who have intimate experience with the struggles, failures, and successes of online learning programs. The series consisted of this post with “Why Online Programs Fail, and 5 Things We Can Do About It” by Sean Michael Morris and Jesse Stommel, “The Early Days of Videotaped Lectures” by Audrey Watters, and “How Not to Teach Online: A Story in Two Parts” by Bonnie Stewart.

Image by Sergey Kochkarev licensed CC-0

]]>
52954
The Flip That Matters https://umwdtlt.com/the-flip-that-matters/ Tue, 12 Jul 2016 13:29:10 +0000 http://umwdtlt.com/?p=405 When you read about the flipped (or inverted) classroom in the media, the focus is almost always on course content. Look at this new way to “deliver” education to our students! And it’s personalized! The focus is typically on video, the internet, how the digital revolution will disrupt education as we know it.

I get it. Tech sells. New, shiny gadgets are exciting. Everyone is, or should be, an entrepreneur … an “edupreneur.” But is replacing a book with a video or a multimedia website really worth all the fuss? (Full disclosure: I am part of an effort to replace a book with a multimedia website.)

If education is purely about content delivery, then no, it’s probably not worth the fuss.

But if education were primarily about content delivery, then why didn’t the printing press kill the school? Why should we assume streaming video on the internet will fare any better? Do we really believe that Salman Khan knows something that Johannes Gutenberg did not?

No, neither education in general, nor the flipped classroom in particular, is about the content. Certainly access to information is important, but what makes the flipped classroom so potentially exciting is not the way that we get information to our students. Education is about the student — their intellectual formation and personal empowerment. And it’s what the flipped classroom has to offer that vision that makes it so potentially exciting for educators.

But let’s step back. Just what is the flipped classroom? If we follow the media hype and the ed-tech marketing pitches,

“The flipped classroom is a pedagogical model in which the typical lecture and homework models of a course are reversed… . The video lecture is often seen as the key ingredient in the flipped approach” (Educause, “7 Things You Should Know about Flipped Classrooms”).

Education World defines the flipped class similarly:

using Web-enabled instructional strategies that allow educators to spend class time interacting with students rather than lecturing.

For Education World, this newly facilitated interaction is largely one-on-one, and the web content highlighted by them is from Khan Academy and Ted-Ed.

Khan Academy themselves define the flipped class as “online delivery of content and instruction,” and they emphasize that the flipped class is an entry point for blended learning and a vehicle for personalization.

Pascal-Emmanuel Gabry (Forbes Magazine) also defines the flipped class exclusively in terms of video, with personalization being the primary goal.

It’s not difficult to see the business model in this video-centric definition. Textbook publishing is still, in many disciplines, a lucrative business. Video creators like Khan Academy can tap into this market, especially if a video-centric definition of the flipped classroom allows them to bill their one-size-fits-all content as an integral part of a so-called “personalized” pedagogy.

In spite of the dominance of the edupreneurial perspective in the media, those who research the flipped classroom (and those who pioneered its implementation) view it differently. Instead of focusing on content delivery and “personalized” learning, pedagogues and pedagogy researchers tend to emphasize the increased focus on active-learning strategies and higher-level reasoning that the flipped class affords. As a result, content plays a supporting role, and for many, technological choices are ancillary to the definition of the flipped class.

Take, for instance, the often cited article, “Inverting the Classroom: A Gateway to Creating an Inclusive Learning Environment,” by Lage et al. (2000):

Inverting the classroom means that events that have traditionally taken place inside the classroom now take place outside the classroom and vice versa (p. 32).

Interestingly, though perhaps not surprisingly in 2000, their study made use of a textbook to facilitate out-of-class information delivery. Video tapes of lectures were offered, but only as a supplemental resource.

More recently, video has become more commonplace in flipped classes, but scholarly definitions of the flipped classroom are broader. For example, in an interview about the information delivery in his flipped pedagogical approach, Eric Mazur quipped:

I used the greatest invention in information technology, the book… . [Y]ou don’t need a video lecture.

We see this sentiment from a number of pedagogy researchers: the technology used to transmit information doesn’t matter; what matters is what active-learning strategies can be employed in class as a result of the new-found time. For example, Julie Schell states that the flipped classroom can involve a pre-class video or reading at home, with in-class activities focused on applying knowledge. Schell also emphasizes the importance of student agency and higher-level cognitive skills as cornerstones of student-centered, flipped learning. Similarly, Derek Bruff writes that the flipped class begins with pre-class readings or videos, but then students “spend class time deepening their understanding of that content through active learning exercises.” This focus on deep understanding and application is an emphasis that my colleagues and I share: “[T]he use of [digital] technology is not even necessary.”

It is easy to get caught up in the media energy of all the new tech tools we as teachers have at our disposal. It is also tempting to grow weary of all the “disruption” and “revolution” around us and say, “You know what? This is all just hype. I was doing fine before, and I can’t keep up with it all anyway. I’ll just do what I’ve always done.” I don’t think either of these perspectives serves our students well.

We have a responsibility when evaluating our own teaching to exercise the same skepticism and critical thought we expect of our students. Ed-tech marketing may be masquerading as pedagogical philosophy, but we must not throw the pedagogical baby out with the technological bath water.

Ultimately, the flipped classroom shifts the emphasis of a class from content delivery to higher-level thinking and application, from the instructor’s activity to the students’ work. That is the flip that matters. Decisions about when and where to do what are secondary, and decisions about technology are even less a priority. John Dewey wrote, “To the growth of the [student] all studies are subservient.” That student-centeredness is at the core of the flipped class. As long as we don’t get lost in the technology marketing hype.

Photo by aptmetaphor (CC BY-ND).

]]>
50769
Building Community Online https://umwdtlt.com/building-community-online/ Mon, 25 Apr 2016 17:43:36 +0000 http://umwdtlt.com/?p=318 As an Online Learning & LMS Specialist, one of the chief concerns faculty bring to me isn’t about the technology — it’s about building community. The culture or atmosphere we create in our courses can drastically change the level of engagement and the depth of learning. We know that it’s something students want from their online courses, too. But how do we build community when when class takes place asynchronously on a screen, rather than together in a classroom? And, conversely, how can we use technology to enhance the community the students experience in the traditional classroom?

As more courses are offered in online and hybrid formats, instructors will need to rethink how they build community and foster interaction in their courses. Communication in a learning management system, on Twitter, or via a blog is different than the type of interaction we’re used to facilitating face-to-face in a classroom.

To tackle this question, we decided to kick off the Division of Teaching and Learning Technologies’ #DoOO series of panel discussions by talking about the ways our faculty and students have fostered community and interaction using a variety of digital tools in their courses.

  

Panelists included:

Martha Burtis – Director, Digital Knowledge Center (@mburtis)
Jeanine Davis – Assistant Professor, Education (@janinesdavis)
Claudine Ferrell – Professor, History
Nora Forknall – Senior, Biology and German major, Chemistry minor, and DKC Tutor (@agent_forknall)
Parrish Waters – Assistant Professor, Biology
Zach Whalen – Associate Professor, English (@zachwhalen)
Lee Skallerup-Bessette (Moderator) – Instructional Technology Specialist – DTLT

The panelists covered a lot of ground, describing a wide variety of approaches and tools they’ve used to foster community including Canvas, BluePulse, blogs, Twitter, Facebook, and Slack. Whether on the password-protected pages of Canvas or Slack, or publicly on Twitter or in a blog, the panelists generally had success, but found that the medium influenced how that community took shape.

One of my favorite points from the discussion was made by Zach Whalen, who reminded us that “silliness can help build community.” Of course, we want students to achieve the learning objectives and complete assignments, but community is more than a group of people independently performing the same tasks. Even in a single classroom, community is complex and multifaceted. A student asks a thought-provoking question. The professor gets sidetracked. The fire alarm goes off. When we move our courses online, we should think about the ways we can foster these shared interactions.

Especially in the early days of the semester, modeling your expectations is one way to encourage quality participation. Martha Burtis explained the motto used by DS106 instructors: “We eat our own dog food.” By this, she means that instructors completed the assignments alongside students to model what they were looking for and to engage with the students in class discussions. Modeling doesn’t just help set expectations, it also helps students feel connected to their instructor, which can increase students’ willingness to participate and improve student learning.

Student agency was also a topic the panel circled around — both in how and when students interact with one another, and how the instructor interacts in these moments. When students have a hand in shaping the conversations while the instructor remains attentive and receptive, allows for greater student ownership over their learning. This not only helps foster community, but also student engagement more generally. The students take pride in what they build.

The panel was wide-ranging in their discussion — far more than I can cover here. Join in the discussion in the comments or on Twitter through #DoOO.



[Photo “Moss Spores” by Benjamin Balázs licensed CC0 1.0]

]]>
50760